Cape May Peanut Butter Co.

Note: The owner or a representative of this business has not yet completed the verification process

See more Terms of Service

4.7

( 8 reviews )

Specialty Food, Delis, Sandwiches

Closed 10:00 AM - 05:00 PM See Hours

516 Carpenters Ln, Cape May, NJ 08204, United States

+1 6989-844-44.0

Introducing Cape May Peanut Butter Co., a cozy counter-serve café located in Cape May, NJ. Known for their delectable homemade nut butters and gourmet sandwiches, this charming establishment offers a unique experience for peanut butter enthusiasts. With a variety of flavors to choose from, Cape May Peanut Butter Co. takes pride in creating their nut butter concoctions in-house, ensuring freshness and quality. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or a flavorful coffee to start your day, this café has you covered. The friendly and welcoming staff aim to provide exceptional service, making every visit memorable. So, whether you're a local resident or a visitor passing through Cape May, stop by Cape May Peanut Butter Co. and indulge in their mouthwatering creations.

Reviews

4.7/5

8 reviews

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 stars

Cel lalata

March 22, 2024

Absolutely lovely. The staff was so sweet and friendly! Loved the honey and my dogs enjoyed their peanut butter dog treats

Jeff schenk

March 22, 2024

Great peanut butter product, love picking them up in person as Smithville is a very cute place to visit. But staff at the store always seem to be annoyed. Not a pleasant experience. Work on that or close up shop.

James mcknight

March 22, 2024

My husband loves peanut butter so we quickly went in when we saw it through the alley of the main thoroughfare. The woman inside was very nice and encouraged us to sample the different butters. I like the almond butter and my husband also liked the cashew butter. There were also ghost pepper peanuts which were super spicy and we got a large container. I had to eat a peanut butter malted milk ball to get the spicey taste out. And I bought a bag of that as well! Great little shop.

Linda ickes

March 22, 2024

Cookies are DRY as a desert. Do not let the smell of this place fool you. Are they serving cookies that are days old?? There’s no reason why the cookies should be this stale and stiff. Staff wasn’t that friendly either. I felt as though they just wanted me to leave, and I was an inconvenience to their day. Really not a great experience at all.

Jen cooper

March 22, 2024

Excellent staff and gourmet peanuts a must stop in Cape May Gourmet tasting of several. Customized peanut butter flavors. Great stop for families and peanut butter lovers. Easy walk from Congress Hall and you are located at the Washington Street outdoor mall.

Barry chaffin

March 22, 2024

I bought this one to hold me over until my favorite cappuccino peanut butter was back in stocks! As always the Cape May Peanut Butter Company never disappoints! I even place online orders throughout the year because it would cost more than tolls and gas to get down so in between vacations, I place orders online! I have never tasted a bad batch in the store and my dog absolutely LOVES their peanut butter dog treats!

Ehasan shawan

March 22, 2024

Great boutique store specializing in peanut butter and jams. There are free samples available and the staff walks around with samples of the bakery products. Store is really small so couple of customers in there makes it really cramped.

Shelly hathaway

March 22, 2024

I bought their Bananas Foster small-batch/high-price peanut butter. Flavor was ok, not great, but the TEXTURE WAS HORRIBLE. It felt like dried peanuts in your mouth, definitely NOT SPREADABLE. And their labeling doesn't have nutrition facts or even the company address...how is that even legal??